The Blame Game
When calamity strikes, whether that be on a personal or public scale, there can often be a clamour for explanation. Why! This is almost an instinctual response we make as we look for sense in it all. And it can lead some to blame God… why was it allowed to happen? It can then be suggested there must have been some malpractice, or even sin, to explain the crisis. Even if not explicitly believed, this notion – that God metes out justice on earth in a Santa Claus kind of way – can linger and corrode any faith we might hold in a good, generous God.
This can often mean our own moral compass is set in a clear-cut binary system – where the good is rewarded and the bad punished. Maybe it goes back to that justice system where scores must be settled– both on a personal and public level.
In Luke 13 Jesus is challenged with such a viewpoint. Jesus is reminded about an incident where the blood of some Galileans was mixed with their sacrifices by Pilate. It may have been some Galileans protesting or acting against the Roman Imperial power and were upbraided at the time of sacrifice – then killed by the Roman authorities with their blood mingled with the blood of the animals. So, were these activist Galileans worse sinners than all the other Galileans whose dissatisfaction was kept much more private. Jesus pronounces a very definitive ‘I tell you, no!’ The original Aramaic testifies to the vehemence of Jesus’ rebuttal. And Jesus then references the falling of the tower of Siloam – situated at the foot of the Temple – where originally there was only a gentle walk up to the Temple. But then King Herod built the holy esplanade structure, the Temple Mount, which loomed high over Siloam, and so maybe the Siloam Tower was constructed as an act of vanity to rival the esplanade. Anyway, Jesus tells us that when the Tower fell (maybe due to an earth tremor) 18 people were crushed to death. So, were these 18 ‘more guilty than all the others living in Jerusalem’? Jesus provides the unequivocable ‘I tell you, no!’
Here Jesus is underlining again that God is not involved any tit-for-tat kind of justice. And each time Jesus provides the warning, ‘but unless you repent, you also will perish’. What is it then we must do – what is this repenting all about?
Well, Jesus gives us the parable of the fig tree to help us understand. The owner of the vineyard had a fig tree growing on his land – it would usually have been in the prime NE location of the vineyard where there would be maximum sunshine. And the leaves of the tree would extend to cover a large area – with nothing growing underneath its reach. So, you would think – if after 3 years – there had been no fruit, just cut it down. The gardener (or worker) resists the owner’s direction: just give me time to dig around the tree, manure will be turned in, and if fruit then bears great, if not cut it down. As we know, the gardener is a metaphor Jesus uses for God’s work – and here again God refuses the day of vengeance and calls in a day of mercy. It is mercy not vengeance which will bring forth life.
Once again Jesus reaffirms God has nothing to do with the day of vengeance -the tree is to be spared to allow mercy and forgiveness to work the soil. God’s way is one of mercy, which when turned into the earth brings forth new life. The repentance we are called into is that willingness to allow ourselves to be ‘turned’ from vengeance and score settling to a life of loving kindness and grace. We consciously let this happen to the degree we permit the gardener to do his work in us and through us. Life then begins to happen! Amen.
